• Welcome to Bare Knuckle Pickups Forum.
 

Practise amp or Gigging amp with attenuator?

Started by rahnooo, January 25, 2006, 01:14:58 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which do you use / prefer for studio and home use?

Dedicated practise amp
10 (43.5%)
Gigging amp, but with an attenuator
13 (56.5%)

Total Members Voted: 23

Voting closed: January 25, 2006, 01:14:58 PM

rahnooo

The title says it all really.

Just out of interest, what would you all prefer to play through at home/in the studio?

* A low wattage practise amp (cornford harlequin/matamp minimat etc)

OR

* A gigging size amp through an attenuator (hotplate/airbrake etc)

I just thought it'd be interested to see what other people were using or would prefer to use :)

Cheers

*Rahnooo*
Mules
Blackguard '55 Staggered
Matamp El84 Minimat.

willo

I went with gig amp/attenuator, because that way I can work on my tone, and its not going to surprise me when I gig. Also, I have to keep my gigging amp in my room anyway, so I figured it would be rather pointless to have two amps in the same room, and only use one.
The large print giveth, and the small print taketh away...

The amazing Phil

Personally I'd go with a smaller amp you can crank in the house, then throw it into a 4X12 and mic it up when you have to. Tone over wattage every single time.

There's a thread somewhere dispelling a lot of the myths inherant in amps, including the one that you need mega-wattage to play live.

Jp.

I went with the smaller amp option.... only coz thats all I have at the moment.

I borrow all my amps :lol:
Mule, Irish Tour and Slowhands

dave_mc

gigging amp.

i don't even use an attenuator, i just turn the master volume down.

sounds a hell of a lot better than any practice amp i've heard/played (unless you're talking about a cornford carrerra or something...)

chrisola

i use the amp + attenuator... low wattage good sounding amps are stupidly expensive and limited imo... makes more sense to spend my cash on a decent amp all round and attenuate it down!

plus, you get the same sound when you crank it, unlike having a gigging amp and a smaller practice amp (unless you can find a manufacturer whos 5w amp sounds the same as a 50w version!)
"Turbo F***ing Spinning PILEDRIVER!!!"

indysmith

i can only afford a gigging amp, i don't have money for a practice amp that sounds good aswell :o
[size=9px]LOVING the Mules![/size]

HJM

Just go with the tone, for somethings a small amp will allways give the right results, but equally sometimes you need the tone from a big amp. No 10w amp will have the bottom end of a 100w amp, no 100w amp will break up like a fender delux or champ......pick the right tool for the job!

I'd go and try a few of each (big and small amps) buy the one that gets you the tone. If you buy a 5w amp though you'll still find it really loud when you get the power valves overdriving!!
Apache,VHII,Emerald,Nailbomb,MiracleMan,StormyMonday,BlackDog,Trilogy,Mothersmilk,Sultans+Sinner

Spook Fish

The problem with attenuators is they shorten the life of your tubes, even though i would say it makes life a little easier and less costly to have one set up you dont want to mess with and keep a firm hold on your tone.


i personally believe the 'right tool for the job' approach and as HJM said previous, a 10 watt valve amp is still kick ass but not much bottom end unless you hook up a cab, or go through a PA with fat speakers.

however, the natural breakup is better on a small amp maxed than a big amp maxed out with an attenuater or power soak, just my opinion:-) or my ears!

Neemo

slow music for slow people

HJM

Actually, if I only needed clean, I'd get a big amp like a twin with lots of headroom......you can't do that with a little amp!!! If I only played crunchy blues, then a small amp would be great.
Apache,VHII,Emerald,Nailbomb,MiracleMan,StormyMonday,BlackDog,Trilogy,Mothersmilk,Sultans+Sinner

rinse_master

I voted for clean, but I guess I'd be somwhere in the middle, I certainly wouldn't have a 100w stack, maybe like 20w, small gig amp?
"What frequency are you getting? Is it noise or sweet, sweet music?"

Bainzy

Quote from: Spook FishThe problem with attenuators is they shorten the life of your tubes, even though i would say it makes life a little easier and less costly to have one set up you dont want to mess with and keep a firm hold on your tone.

Your tubes won't last any longer cranking them without an attenuator - the reason your tubes don't last as long is an attenuator encourages you to crank the amp more.
[url=http://www.pleximods.com]Plexi Mods[/url]
[url=http://www.shredaholic.com]Free Shred Guitar Lessons[/url]

rahnooo

Quote from: HJMActually, if I only needed clean, I'd get a big amp like a twin with lots of headroom......you can't do that with a little amp!!! If I only played crunchy blues, then a small amp would be great.

Something tells me you have a multi-amp set up going on Hayden. I know it's off topic (but to hell with it, it's my topic) what are your opinions on clean-dirty A/B set ups? The mini-mat is still very appealing and I'm thinking of having it as the dirty half of a set up with my ashdown. Just musing though... This topic was really just out of interest to see what people were using/aspiring to :)

*Rahnooo*
Mules
Blackguard '55 Staggered
Matamp El84 Minimat.

HJM

I'm using a Fender Super Reverb for clean and a Marshall JCM8000 2204 for dirty. It's a lot to carry but works well!! I do have a C7 Matamp too that I can use if I want to have a third sound with an A/B/C pedal.

I've had to get some Ebtech  hum elliminators in to kill ground loops, and a good A/B/C switch - I use the Lehle box, 1@3 I think!!

What I take depends on the gig, if it's just overdrive I'll use two Marshalls controled from the volume pot with an SD1 as a boost. If I need a blues tone the C7 is great, or the Super Reverb for cleans with a TS9 for blues leads.

I'm lucky to have got most of these amps really cheap, if I had to choose one I'd probably go with a Matamp 1224, you can run it on one valve or two valves class A, and 2 or 4 valves in Class AB. Best of both worlds!! (or at least it was before Mesa stole the idea and tried to patent it!!)
Apache,VHII,Emerald,Nailbomb,MiracleMan,StormyMonday,BlackDog,Trilogy,Mothersmilk,Sultans+Sinner