I would replace the Tone pot. You need to get one with the same value (probably 250K for a P-90 though Gibson have used 500K). Connect the existing wires to the new pot exactly as they are on the old one. Unsolder the live wire from the volume and put it to one of the outside tags on the switch (there a 2 lots of 3). Take the tap wire to the tag on the opposite end (so now you have a row of 3 with Main, nothing, Tap). Take a wire from the center to the volume (the tag where you disconnected the pickup wire).
That's it.