I don't mind if sound in little compressed, I just want pickup that will sound really fat and organic but that will give me good chord clarity and cut good! I play a lot of chords with tremolo picking technique.
Guitar is Les Paul Custom (with maple top, mahogany body and neck) and full wood, very heavy!
On clips I found on internet, C-Pig seems to be the fattest sounding, but I don't know how good it cuts in mix and live situations, I am also worried if it will have too much bass. Tim recommended me Aftermath, but I am not sure, because it sound a lot thinner on some clips...
Keep in mind that I usually like to make a sound of guitar little scooped...