Thanks for the reply Hammer, I am playing with an older axe fx through a Mesa 2:100 and a custom cab with what are pretty much greenback speakers. I can achieve a fair variety of tones, but pickups make a huge difference.
I am going to pull the trigger on this and get the warpig. Of the tons of clips I've listened to over the years they are the only one that I never hear any annoying or awkward frequencies, but I always talk myself out of them. I'm definitely not looking for 80's tone, I'm a modern type of guy, and the band I play in does more of its black metal side with technique and structure while using a mostly modern death metal tone. That to me puts out the HD based on what I've heard.
I'm going with ceramic based on an email to BKP, just because I'm worried about things getting too dark, although the woods I have are quality, they can tend to be darker or sweeter than say, a guitar with any amount of maple in it.