• Welcome to Bare Knuckle Pickups Forum.
 

Myths about Poplar... Opinions appreciated!

Started by GuitarIv, May 20, 2013, 10:30:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Philly Q

Quote from: WezV on May 21, 2013, 05:25:13 PM
if you had brought a cheeap factory guitar made from poplar and it sounded amazing i would say "you got lucky".   

And of course the same would be true of a cheap factory guitar made from alder, basswood, nato or whatever. 
BKPs I've Got:  RR, BKP-91, ITs, VHII, CS set, Emeralds
BKPs I Had:  RY+Abraxas, Crawlers, BD+SM

GuitarIv

Well, I just had a chat with my luthier yesterday about Poplar. He told me that he despised the wood for a long time, however the Hungarian Swamp Poplar he used for my guitar is the superior equivalent to the more common Chinese and American sort used in mass production, the main difference being the wood growth pattern. Whereas the inferior type doesn't grow straight and has often crooked wood pattern areas, resulting in the unsatisfying sound, the Hungarian species grows steady and straight, being light, very well to work with and having a transparent tone with a defined bottom end, rich mids and highs and a healthy presence. He even told me he knocked on the wood to hear the acoustic properties before selecting said piece and putting it together with the Canadian Maple for the Neck and Fretboard, resulting in a cutting, defined and ultimately light guitar that fits my needs. There soo much more to building a guitar then most people could imagine...  :o

Zaned

Quote from: GuitarIv on May 28, 2013, 02:26:39 PM
Well, I just had a chat with my luthier yesterday about Poplar. He told me that he despised the wood for a long time, however the Hungarian Swamp Poplar he used for my guitar is the superior equivalent to the more common Chinese and American sort used in mass production, the main difference being the wood growth pattern. Whereas the inferior type doesn't grow straight and has often crooked wood pattern areas, resulting in the unsatisfying sound, the Hungarian species grows steady and straight, being light, very well to work with and having a transparent tone with a defined bottom end, rich mids and highs and a healthy presence. He even told me he knocked on the wood to hear the acoustic properties before selecting said piece and putting it together with the Canadian Maple for the Neck and Fretboard, resulting in a cutting, defined and ultimately light guitar that fits my needs. There soo much more to building a guitar then most people could imagine...  :o

That's what luthiers do when selecting woods. I actually got to try the wood pieces of my custom strat (actually, chose the fretboard and top) before they were assembled. The body had been cut to a strat shape, but didn't have contours yet.

When he knocked on the body wood, you could tell that it would be very clear in tone; absolutely no mud.

-Zaned
Paths are for followers.