Quote from: Nadz1lla on August 14, 2013, 11:37:46 PM
I couldn't comment on the giving lessons part, but I can relate to the Police being a let-down. My Dad just retired from the Police (he did 24 years in the Royal Marines, then joined the Police as a bobby when he came out at 40 and has been on the beat until "chucking out" time).
He said he enjoyed making a difference when he could, but the fatal combination of too much red tape and people who shouldn't have anything to do with "law enforcement" because of their easy corruptibility and laziness finally ground him down. He still worked out his full time to retirement, made great friends and helped put some proper scum behind bars, but was horrified at some of the utter scum behind the desks in the service. I have to say I agree. Someone tried to stitch him up and really had it in for him, but then they got caught breaking in to his locker so they're being investigated.
Add to that the way our government seems to want to actively dissuade people from keeping our streets safe, or care for others in our communities and healthcare... bad times.
I can see that. I could write 10 pages about the rights and wrongs of the job but its also down to the government, the media, peoples perceptions, misunderstandings and of course the odd bad egg! I hate the impact it has on my social life i.e the shifts, knowing if I do any thing semi dodgy people will judge me or go to the papers and most of all when I first meet people and tell them what I do its like theres a massive reaction either 'That's mega interesting' or 'I hate the police' and all I want to do is turn around and say 'Its my day off I don't get many, I want to drink my self senseless not talk about my job and the rights and wrongs of it / society and what you find interesting I find tedious and serious not a game'. If I said that though people would think im rude and all coppers are rude so catch ARRRRGHHHH. Any way its not a sob story im lucky to have a job and its my choice if I do it or not! My Dad did it too and it was a massive reason things didn't work out between him and my mum.
On to the theory side I appreciate your honesty but it isn't realistic to start theory from the basics when I just don't have a need for it :/ Ive been to 4 guitar teachers and 3 of the 4 never tried to 'push' theory on me at all. The 4th was a classical guitarist so that it was essential to read music and do every thing to the rules....it didn't last long haha. As far as making music fit together my 3rd and best guitar teacher just said 'Use your ears and write one part at a time and check they work together bit by bit' and that made sense to me and ive stuck by it.
So in short I know I have a good manner, communication skills, technique a decent level of experience and a ton of passion but the theory well.... I know beginners who know more.
George Lynch claims to not know any theory and he does online lessons maybe I should check them out.....maybe hes being modest OR hes just plain lying giving it the 'I just drank lots of beer and $%&#ed loads of girls and picked up guitar instantly vibe'. I mean eddie van halen claims to not know any theory but he was an accomplished pianist at a young age so that doesn't check out.....
Marty Friedman says he didn't know theory and he taught but was he being truthful? He has a crazy style which kinda doesn't make sense or follow any rules so maybe so and I know my playing is a bit off the wall/progressive.
I think famous/great guitarists do play down their knowledge of theory they probably think it makes them look cooler or seem like they have a natural gift.