Check out Guitar and Bass mag this month (the one with Chuck Berry on the cover). They have a shoot out between analog style delays and you can see the price ranges too. I have a Strymon El Capistan and a Danelectro Reel Echo, both of which are reviewed.
For the overdrive I would go with something like a Klon Clone (Juansolo on this site makes great ones), or perhaps an Xotic Effects AC boost or BB preamp, though any of the 808 styles are good too. If you go to the Prymaxe Vintage web site, they have all the pedals with many of them demo'd.
For a fuzz, you could go for one of the new Fuzz Face mini's (there is the Jimi Hendrix model), Death By Audio Fuzz War or, one of my favourites, the Mojo Hand Iron Bell.
For something a bit different look at the Mad Professor Golden Cello, which is an overdrive with delay built in.
Of course all guitarists will give you lots of different options (I have lots of overdrives and fuzzes and can never make my mind up which is my favourite either).