A quick summary:
Mule - open and dynamic 59 PAF - AIV-magnet
Abraxas - hotrodded Mule - more mids, less topend and compression than the Mule - AIV-magnet
Crawler - über-Mule - juicy, thick tones, round, but not dull topend and more compressed than the Abraxas - AV-magnet
Crawler can be a hit or miss in Les Pauls, but a bright one could benefit from it's bold tones.
VHII can be a hit or miss in a Les Paul: hot classic PAF, quite balanced, but compared to the Mule, more bass. Nearly uncompressed, very vocal, but also - to my ears - a little dry. Screams when you dig in, because it's a very touchsensitive pickup. The VHII performs most of the time well in alder/ash bolt-on guitars. In Les Pauls it's not everybody's darling.
My recommendation - based on your description - would be: Abraxas-bridge/Mule-neck.