Hi and welcome mate!
Would you be so kind to give us more info on what kind of guitar you have? Scale length and contruction can make a big impact. With basswood body I assume it to be in the superstrat region, but I canīt tell.
Now, even though I am lacking details here I would drift towards the Mule. Pure gold standard ī59 PAF sound. Warmer than the Riff Raff which excells in really warm and middy guitars which could be on the darker end. The Mule always works though. The polar oposite of a one trick pony.
So yeah, probably Mule for you, but give us more details so we can be sure. =)