I've messaged BKP, but it would be nice to hear your thoughts as well. So I'll just copy and paste the message :)
Dear BKP,
Thanks again for the advice a couple weeks ago. But my search has moved on to something different this time...
I decided to do something different to my Hard Rock band, and decided on pushing the boundaries of my musical abilities, and start forming a Symphonic Metal band. Kind of like Within Temptation, Nightwish, Epica, etc... and wondered what a goo set of recording, as well as live pickups, would work. Rather than having the guitar as the driving force of the band, I'm wanting to use orchestral scores to build up the weight of the sound, and need something that can keep up with the heavy layers of instruments, and not get lost in the mix. Whilst Symphonic Metal has it's heavy moments, here will be lighter moments as well. Plus having solos, it would be great for something musical and expressive. But rhythm will be the main driving force. So preferably a bridge pickup that can cater to this.
Being a Musicman Silhouette (Alder/Maple/Ebony), it has 2 single coils as well, so I'm looking for something which can provide the clean tones, but at the same time, keep up if gain is applied. I'm not after hendrixy clean tones. But it would be nice to have a sort of paino-esque sound the arpeggiated chords. Again being able to sit nicely in a dense mix.
Something else I wanted to ask is that I'm looking to replace my Emerald neck. Whilst it's a sweet sounding pickup, and the clarity is great...I just don't feel it's for me. When playing it through gain, and turning down the volume control to clean it up, it just goes too polite for my liking, and isn't sharp enough in the treble department. I'm preferably after a neck pickup that has good cleans, but rather than going muddy with gain, it tightens up for a more precise attack. I know a lot of players like to hide behind the gain and mud, but I prefer each picked note to sound resolute. I like the attack. Have you any recommendations for this?