« Reply #1 on: August 22, 2016, 12:28:26 PM »
I think out of those two you'd be safer going with the Jugg (I have some experience as I only build and play 7-strings and have a couple of evertune'd 7's). The black dog is great but it does seem to be very guitar dependant - I always found it fat and throaty, but others commented that it was very treble'y in their guitars, and then I tried it in a different guitar and found that it was quite treble'y too! It's never unpleasant but to get that fat sound out of it seems to depend more on it going in the 'right' guitar compared to other pickups. It also feels a lot lower in output, a lot more vintage in feel, compared to something like the Jugg, so you might find it feels a bit lacking in output unless you're really looking for that dynamic vintage feel. I would try Juggs first for a fat throaty sound :)

Logged
Bridge: (A)Pig, HD, Jugg, PK, (A)NB, Crawler, Aftermath, RY, Abraxas, Emerald, BD, VHII, RR, Cobra, Sinner, Trilogy, Stockholm, Supermassive.
Neck: IT, SM, CS, Trilogy, Emerald, Cobra, Blue note.