If I push far more than I deem sensible, they go half way on and slightly chew the inside. When I then give up I need to use something to splay out the split shaft so the old ones (original, and fender/allparts replacements) aren't loose and don't spin too freely. So far to different to account for sligh snugness difference.
The vintage replacement knob sets are from Teisco and Hofner, so if they're japanese/german respectively, then I guess it'd make sense if these were metric shaft pots instread of the usual imperial fender/gibson and other US company ones.
So, where would I find good quality metric split knurled-shaft pots? Most parts shops don't seem to ever mention whether they are imperial/metric and just state smooth/split or long/short (so I assume imperial by default).
I can just go googling for any old metric pots if the theory is correct, but that doesn't mean they're any good for guitars...