I’ve played most of the pickups mentioned in this thread (except Rebel Yells but that’s going to change soon as I just got a set). The Abraxas/Crawler/Holy Diver will all thicken up your guitar. The Abraxas is the most vintage. I tried that in a (rather dark sounding) PRS SE Tremonti that I nodded for a friend. It definitely has a midrange push, but the tone is very balanced. For my taste, it didn’t have enough high end sparkle in a darker PRS, but it could work in your case. It is the most vintage voiced of the three and responds well to changes in the tone controls on your amp because it is so balanced. The Crawler is hotter with more kids and a rounded top end. I have it in a very bright Super strat and the rounded top end works perfectly in that guitar to prevent ice picky highs, but it was a little too dark for me in a different Strat. The Holy Diver also went into a Super Strat (that isn’t as bright as the one with the Crawler). It isn’t modern voiced but is definitely more modern than the Abraxas/Crawler. It’s hotter as well. The Holy Diver has a lot of low end which works great to fatten up a Strat, but I could see it being too much in some Les Pauls. The Rebel Yell and Holy Diver both share some JB DNA, but they are voiced differently. I hope this helps!