Curious, I don't think there's a pickup in the bkp catalogue (and among other brands) that got so much hate. Good that works for you anyway.
I was even thinking of buying another one(!)
edit: what was the hate about actually? the aftermath even won a couple of awards if I remember correctly.
Apart from what Sloven said, the aftermaths are considered quirurgical cold and harsh pickups, a one horse set according to other "more populated" forums. But, as Dave said, it's just a matter of that day's trend. First the EMG were cool, then everybody hated actives and especially EMG until the 57/66 or whatever arrived, After that the Nazgul was the best, which also got bashed pretty heavily, then came BKP and everybody loved them, the Black Winters were the new to-go set, and now everybody drools for a Fishman set.