I've tried Warpigs in 2 guitars, a BC Rich with a Nato (Eastern Mahogany) body and a my Gibson Les Paul.
In the BC Rich they improved the sound by a factor of 10. Powerful, full, with plenty of definition to the tone even when tuned down. In the Les Paul I find myself turning down the Bass and Mid and turning up the Treble, but I still can't get as good a sound. Plus it just doesn't sound like a Les Paul any more.
The other thing is, you said you want 'tight bass' with 'nice highs for solos'. This isn't the Warpig in any guitar let alone a Les Paul. Sounds like you were right on the money when you mentioned the MM.