i started on a yamaha pacifica (strat style) and moved on to an ibanez s series (superstrat style), but lately i've just bought a les paul junior and a les paul custom. I love having them, they feel far more chunky, and they sound a whole lot 'meatier' with more mids. However, i think i play better on what i'm used to. the les pauls appeal to me when i want something thick, brutal and pure rawk, however, i always feel that the strats (ibanez especially) is far more practical and versatile than the les paul. It's lighter, got more pickup selections, an easier-to-handle neck, never EVER goes out of tune, oh, and it's got that trem bar that i'm constantly reaching for and not finding whilst playing my LPs.
Yep, if i had to choose one of my guitars to come to the desert island it'd be the Ibanez. Sounds weird, but it also seems stronger. the Ibanez is (metaphorically) a thin rod of titanium and carbon whereas the les pauls are big clubs of wood.