:D Oh come on folks. We're guitarists, right?
One is too many, a thousand is never enough..isn't that what they say?
Of course it's both and always will be until we add "actually I need THAT as well now".
In the early 80s I swore that that was it with buckers, so got rid of the SG, to become for-all-time a "bluesman" with a strat.
Thing was I got to like whammy bars 6 years later and got an Ibanez;
then it was, "oh..something more vintagey", so then there was the Eggle;
then the strat was too "80s" so it was a return to Vintageville with a Jap68RI;
then it was "actually, I have to have a Les Paul or I'll never have one.
Then, my fellow addicts, I just stopped getting rid of guitars in the vain hope that constant GAS-feeding would assuage my lust.
Present housemates are the LP, the Strat, the Yam, the PRS and a really nice LP copy by Vintage, along with a Status S2 5-er..of course I tell myself they are all necessary because of recording(yeahright)...
The moral of the tale being that it is never "both" but "all"...it's just a matter of time... 8)