You're both wrong guys.
Ted's setup is typical Japanese, and Gibson tend to use this setup too. I use audio taper (log) pots for both tone and volume as at gig volumes a drop of volume down to 6 or 7 is perfect for a rhythm setting and boosting up to 10 for solos. At bedroom levels it does sound like the volume rolls off too much though with audio pots.
Ted - try swapping the volume (linear) pots for audio taper and see if you like them, if not you can switch back to linear. As for the noise, that'll be bad wiring or a bad pot - nothing to do with the taper (audio or linear).