dont say that tom. Almost all the guitars i make are natural finish with high gloss lacquer!!!
i know what you mean about those fenders though!
I know organic guitars have done some spalted maple guitars with tru-oil buffed to a semi gloss finish but really i want the practical protection of lacquer with the nice touchable finish of oil.
I might spray gloss lacquer for the strength but knock the shine off it then buff it up with wax to try and achieve a semi-gloss. The problem with just doing satin is that it will buff up to a shine overtime anyway