I can't claim to be an electronics wizard, but I'm not convinced by all that stuff about star grounding and ground loops. People like Hamer and Fender use cavity shielding foil/paint and still have wires connecting the pots together, and I don't believe they're idiots. All those wires and pot chassis ultimately connect to a common ground on the output jack.
I think the star-grounding stuff is much more relevant to complex circuits like amps. The Guitarnuts chap himself says this at the very bottom of the article:
"The star-grounding presented here is important more for protection against white noise and radio interference than 60hz hum. If your guitar came from the factory with foil on the back of the pickguard and a heavy layer of shielding paint in the body cavity then following these instructions for the star grounding is probably only going to give you a barely perceptible reduction in hum."
For my two-penn'orth, I like to use copper foil on the back of scratchplates and conductive paint in cavities. Foil-lining the cavities probably works better (and is cheaper), but it's fiddly to work with, and making the electrical connections when you have to use more than one piece is a pain. And that stuff has bloody sharp edges! :x