first off, i have no idea about business. just so you've been warned... :lol: (i've read through the first page, i'll go back and read through page 2 and 3)
coffee shop sounds like a good idea; however, you'd want to be careful that people aren't eating a greasy sandwich, and then going straight to try the guitars. That couldn't help the condition of the guitars.
i agree with less well known, but good (and good value) brands. Gordon Smith, Japanese Tokais, etc.
problem is, a lot of the gear that more experienced players deem "rubbish", sells extremely well to beginners.
i agree about finding a niche. and tom had some good ideas about after-sales service.
EDIT: ok, read through most of the rest:
(a) With my cynical hat on, I'd say if you want something different in a guitar shop employ staff who aren't arseholes :| . Goes without saying if you run it yourself of course, Dave 8) .
(b) If you specialise in amps (or even just guitars), get some proper soundproof rooms! If you're a donkey of a player like me, it's terribly inhibiting trying out gear in the main showroom - and you can't actually hear anything properly anyway. Result - no sale, even if the money's burning a hole in your pocket.
(a) +1. Far from every music shop worker is a tool, but there are enough that having a nice guy (or guys, or girls) in the shop could make all the difference.
(b) agreed, a soundproof room is awesome. And far too few shops have them.
I think having liquids and guitars in the same place will lead to sticky guitars.
haha, beaten to it.
Some new ideas:
Could you sell second hand stuff on commission? that might be an idea. A lot of people (myself included) are wary of selling something to a shop for, say, £200, and then going in the next day to see it marked for £400. It would mean no money up front for the seller, but at least they'd know how much they were paying for the service.
Kids: I dunno. My thinking (could be way off) that they're only kids for a few years. If you make friends when they're 16, you could have a customer for life. Soundproof rooms could come in handy here if you want to avoid it annoying other more mature customers. Though having several soundproof rooms will doubtless get expensive very, very quickly.
Oh, and have a pedalboard set up at all times. I'm not a big pedal guy, but when i realise that a lot of the time the guy in the shop has to run looking a lead, a battery, an amp, and then you realise you can only try one pedal at a time etc.... more often than not i don't even try the thing. which means i definitely won't buy...