• Welcome to Bare Knuckle Pickups Forum.
 

Mic for backing vox and guitar recording? SM58 or E835?

Started by Twinfan, December 21, 2008, 11:48:17 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Twinfan

I'm thinking of having a dabble with backing vocals in my band, so I'm looking into mics.  Primarily for live use, I need something straightforward.  Our singer uses an SM58, and my DC singer swears by SM58s too so that was my first choice.  I read somewhere that ideally you should all use the same mic live as it helps with the mix - not sure if that's true though.

However.....

I may use it to record guitar parts as well from time to time, and I believe the SM58 isn't best suited to this.  Although I think if you remove the pop shield it can work OK.

Also, I like things that are a little bit different and my search led me to the Sennheiser E-835 which seems to be a good alternative to the '58 and a bit more flexible.  Anyone used one or care to comment?

So should I try the Sennheiser or just get the industry standard SM58?

nfe

What kind of voice do you have? Or rather, how do you sing?

If it's gruffer rocky stuff then I quite like the Sennhiser e935's. If you're covering all bases then I like Audio Technica AE5400.

But, for a trusty, relatively cheap, workhorse mic, you really can't go wrong with SM58s.

rohlfo

same mics on stage does sometimes prove to be useful, espec. if you're cranking levels. The 58 is proven to be a brill, rugged, decent mic.... it's the safe card! I've seen E-835's in use, but can't remember what they were like...not that dissimilar I think. Both should give you a half decent amp recording as well.... obv. the SM57 is better for this, which you could use for B. vox without much hassle...I guess it depends where your priorities lie - singing or recording!
Crawlers, Riff Raffs

Twinfan

Vocals is the priority and I have a reasonably high voice, similar in frequency to Dave Grohl but not as high and I can't scream like him!  I sing fairly musically - I don't 'talk on pitch' like Mark Knopfler.

SM58 or 58A Beta seems like the way to go then?

MrBump

Quote from: Twinfan on December 21, 2008, 12:47:46 PM
Vocals is the priority and I have a reasonably high voice, similar in frequency to Dave Grohl but not as high and I can't scream like him!  I sing fairly musically - I don't 'talk on pitch' like Mark Knopfler.

SM58 or 58A Beta seems like the way to go then?

... are you going to get two...?
BKPs Past and Present - Nailbombs, Mules, Blackguard Flat 50's, VHII's & Trilogy Suite with Neck & Bridge Baseplates!

rohlfo

Quote from: Twinfan on December 21, 2008, 12:47:46 PM
V

SM58 or 58A Beta seems like the way to go then?

I'd go 58....makes sense imo and same type as your singer - helps and looks cool  :D
Crawlers, Riff Raffs

Denim n Leather


Twinfan

Yeah TO, I know I will  :)  Just trying to get one that will be OK at the moment  :)

Stock SM58 it is then.  Cheers guys!

mikeluke

Couple of thoughts:

If you are going to buy a Shure mic make sure you go to a reputable dealer - LOTS of fakes on eBay, some of which are very hard to tell from the real thing - Beta 58 is a better mic than the SM58 but does not have an on/off switch on the mic - you may/may not find this useful! I have both - I use the SM58 for practice and the Beta 58 for gigs.

Good luck!

Mike
Mules, Riff-Raff

Oli

Get the Sennheiser MD421... it's got an adjustable do-dad that sweeps from voice to music, and sounds great on guitar cabs, bass cabs, toms and kick drums, it's really versatile. I can't comment too much on the vocal side of it, but it was designed with that in mind, so it shouldn't be bad. It is a bit more pricey though, but worth it I feel.
Nailbomb, VHII, Warpig 7, MQ, Black Dog, 10th Anniversary

Denim n Leather

Quote from: Twinfan on December 21, 2008, 04:34:51 PM
Yeah TO, I know I will  :)  Just trying to get one that will be OK at the moment  :)

Stock SM58 it is then.  Cheers guys!
I think it's worth getting 2 mics, each specialized for it's purpose. There's a reason why most people don't use a 58 for guitar, nor a 57 for vox, as a gross generalization.

gwEm

denim'n'leather is right - 2 mics would be best. however i use a sm57 very often for vocals - i like the way i can shout into it and not get any ill effects, its quite tolerant of hard sounding Ts etc etc too.
Quote from: AndyRyou wouldn't use the meat knife on crusty bread but, equally, the serrated knife and straight edge knife aren't going to go through raw meat as quickly

Twinfan

I've read that if you remove the pop-shield from an SM58 you've essentially got an SM57 so the SM58 is the one I'll go for.  When I learn how to sing better, and work out what I don't like/don't like about the '58 I'll go mic shopping again  :)

hunter

Tweaker's Paradise - Player's nightmare.

nfe

Quote from: mikeluke on December 21, 2008, 10:11:01 PM
Couple of thoughts:

If you are going to buy a Shure mic make sure you go to a reputable dealer - LOTS of fakes on eBay, some of which are very hard to tell from the real thing - Beta 58 is a better mic than the SM58 but does not have an on/off switch on the mic - you may/may not find this useful! I have both - I use the SM58 for practice and the Beta 58 for gigs.

Good luck!

Mike

The SM58 doesn't have an on/off in any version...  :?Well, bar the radio mic  :lol:

As a general rule, on/off switches are a terrible idea on mics. Fastest way to silence yourself onstage by accident and easiest way to spike a PA when you can't work out why you're not getting a signal until...