Maybe it's really just me and my half-deaf pair of heavy metal ears
...
Let's say the CS didn't deliver the warm and singing tone I like in a neck P-up like e.g. a Duncan '59.
yes, you're deaf! :? :lol:
I had both in the same guitar on neck position
the '59 is the most dead, cold, sterile sounding neck pickup I ever had (including stock pups!) :x
no volume, no mids, dead treble, no sustain, muffled and hollow sounding
even the clean tone was cr@p
my mij les paul sounded like a $50 acoustic guitar on both cleans and leads
I played another one in another mij les paul (an edwards) and it was a bit better/brighter, but still scooped and the highs sounded almost "ceramic"
I never cared for neck pickups too much before, but the fact that it sounded worse than stock pickups really annoyed me
even the gibson 496r (ceramic) neck pickup I have now, which is and kinda hard still sounds way more organic