I agree with you 100% - singles win for me all the time. I like buckers, but they just don't have the va va voom I like in my sound.
Just been learning the PBBB version of Born in Chicago - tried it at first with my Mule'd Esprit but just couldn't get it to sound like Bloomfield. Then I tried the Tele with Flat 50s - oh yes, Bloomfield in spades (and today I learned that the reedy sound of early Bloomfield was not his famous LP but a telecaster, so hours of trying to get near his tone with mules was wasted).
It could be an age thing though - apparently Peter Green doesn't own and refuses to own a Les Paul!