Rightly or wrongly, my experience as one of these old-git strat-players tells me that NOTHING sounds like an actual strat... if I want a strat, I'm getting a strat or a well built copy. And I'm afraid that I snort amusing snorting sounds at folks that make things like the above PRS strat-a-like. They're never going to convince the folks like me to get one!! Hell, it is so easy nowadays to get a decent strat with Fender written on it, what sane person who wants a strat is going to get a more expensive guitar that is a bit like but actually isn't a strat?!!
Well, there are people who buy Suhr, Tom Anderson, Tyler, Grosh and things like that.
I'm prepared to believe those guitars are at least on a par with Fender Custom Shop and a lot better than production Fenders.
But - and here's where I'm going to agree with you! :lol: - none of those guitars are as
cool as Fender. And the people who play them tend to far-above-us mere-mortals types like Scott Henderson, Michael Landau.... great players, but they're like surgeons who need guitars which are precision tools. The cool rock'n'roll guys just play Fenders. And it has to be said that's what most people are always going to aspire to.
***********************************************
Back on PRS, I agree with many of the comments above.
I believe the reason PRS have managed to actually compete with the big two - where many others failed - is that they have/had a design philosophy and actually
stuck to it, basing everything round a couple of body shapes, limited options and proprietary pickups and hardware. When they depart from that philosophy something always smells funny.