I think the point is you can get instant mix ready sounds in a studio or have a light portable and very controllable live rig through the house PA. For consistent and controllable results this kind of thing is very valuable to some folks. Just think if you were recording a piece for a commercial or conference or music for TV and you needed one quick quitar line. You are working on your own, do you:-
A. Drag out the 50W Marshall, 4x12, SM57 and Neumann and spend 2 hours getting a good sound or
B. Plug into the Axe FX, play the line, sit it in the mix in 10 mins and move on....
These things are very valuable to studios and in a mix almost nobody could tell the difference. Time is money so for instant and predictable results I can certainly see why people buy these things.
Okay, I'm putting my guitarists hat back on now:-
Valves all the way!!!!!!
That lazy studio git better mic my MJW up becuase I'm not playing through no rack computer :D