Forgive the long post but if I'm asking for advice and opinions it seems only reasonable to give as much info as possible. :D OK, here's the deal. I have a Jackson SL3 with a Miracle Man and Trilogy Suites so that pretty much covers me for Metal. My other guitar is a PRS SE Custom 24 and that is the one I now want to give the BKP treatment to. Here's some of my criteria:
1) I don't need it to do the same as my Jackson but I do need it to be versatile as it is also a backup guitar for gigs so some ability to cover Metal OK would be nice.
2) I want this to be aimed primarily at covering songs up to the point where my Jackson will take over so I'm looking for great clear cleans, a beautiful Blues tone and some great Rock tones that will take a decent chunk of gain.
3) The tone should have real body to it, with punch.
4) The bridge should be crisp, articulate and have a bit of aggression to it. Just enough to give it a bit of bite.
5) The neck should be sweet and creamy. Think of early Dave Murray tone when he was using a PAF in the neck.
6) Between the bridge and neck pickups I'd like to cover the soft and sweet Blues based tones of Santana and the more aggressive, thick and crisp tones of Gary Moore.
Bridge Options
Holydiver - I know this pickup already and I like it. It will do the Rock tones really well, has a great lead tone which is important to me and cleans up OK, though not the most Bluesy of my options. Talking to Tim, he rates this one very highly with an Emerald in the neck for a good range of tones.
VHII - Not one I'd considered before at all but Tim says it works really well in PRS guitars and the clips I've listened to sound very impressive indeed. Superb tone. It sounds rather brighter to me than the Holydiver but not harsh and does seem to have a more PAF vibe to it with its more modest output. My two concerns with this one (probably due to me lack of experience with it) is that the Emerald neck sounds like it would be REALLY good for what I want but I don't think it would go well with a VHII in the bridge so if I used the VHII in the bridge I'd need another neck option. The other slight concern is that I read a few posts saying that the VHII kinda shows up mistakes. I'm not a bad player but I'm a hell of a long way from being really good.
Neck Options
Emerald - I hear incredible things about the Emerald neck, Tim rates it very highly for what I want and the description certainly seems to sound suitable. It should be articulate enough and the AIV magnet will give it some great PAF Blues tones so it sounds like it would be great for both Dave Murray and Santana.
VHII - Again, I know nothing about the VHII so I have no idea if it will do what I want but if I went with a VHII in the bridge, I'm not sure what else I could put with it.
Abraxas - I only mention this one because like the Emerald it's AIV so I assume it shares a number of very similar qualities and if the Emerald is good for the Dave Murray tone it seems reasonable to assume the Abraxas will and I think it would go with the VHII bridge better than the Emerald
So there it is; I'm really stuck. The Emerald sounds ideal for the neck and I'm pretty sure the Holydiver will perform well in the guitar and Tim agrees. However, Tim also thinks that VHII are great pickups for a PRS and I'd be a fool to if I didn't at least consider this suggestion and find out more, especially as the clips I've listened to sound so good.
Thanks :D