The trouble with such a comparison as far as you're concerned is that it ignores the effect of your amp and of course, your amp has the biggest influence on your tone. Your amp is the only reason I suggested something other than the Warpig and is also the reason why I wouldn't so readily dismiss something like the Black Hawk. Your amp is big and dark so the EQ on the Warpig looks all wrong to me whereas the Aftermath's looks better. The Black Hawk shares a similar EQ and gives you both ceramic and alnico options, both of which should work well. The Warpig also always sounds quite big, warm and organic to me in comparison to the Aftermath, which is very tight and dry. I thought about the Black Hawk because it always sounds that bit bigger and more organic than the Aftermath so you get your nod towards the Warpig while retaining all of the clarity etc. you get from the Aftermath. The Black Hawk always sounds a lot more versatile to me too but I hasten to add that this is based only on things I've heard and comments on here as neither suits my own personal tastes - that would only take me to the Warpig but looking at it objectively, I just don't see it suiting your rig as well.
Ultimately of course, it's your money and your choice and I'm sure both will perform extremely well.
