I got a chance to listen to a promo copy the other day too. I'm not so sure about it. The guitar playing is jaw dropping (Matt Heafy is an awesome guitarist, I prefer his solos, tone and general playing to Corey's) but MH is trying SO hard to be James Hetfield IMO. 'The Anthem' is a classic, and there are a few other good ones but to be honest I preferred Ascendency. I know it was all metalcore emo-ish stuff (or whatever it gets categorized into) but I thought they were bloody good at it. At Total Guitar put it, this is the best Metallica album in ages. But no-one sounds great doing Metallica apart from Metallica (well, not these days unfortunately) and their undeniable talent (especially Heafy's) is totally wasted on this album, which should have been called 'And Justice Part Deux'. The title track is a mess too IMO. It's just a mish-mash of time signature and riff changes. They're not Metallica and they should stop trying to be and go back to what they were good at, which was what got them noticed in the first place. Here's hoping album number four will be 'the one' :).