I wanted to avoid making a new thread to not clutter up the forum, but I haven't exactly been able to find a "looking for a new amp" thread in which the threadstarter wanted exactly what I do.
I have about USD $550-600 to spend. I live in America, so American-made amps are going to be cheaper to come by than anything else (I hear there's a lot of markup in Europe; it's not quite as bad here). I'd like a tube amp.
I mostly play metal. The amp I want should have adequate cleans, but it doesn't have to be anything spectacular. I'm not very concerned about the bluesy, low-gain drive - if I want to do that kind of stuff, I can A/B it with a Epi VJ, Fender, Peavey Classic 30, etc.
What I'm expecting is a rhythm channel that is reminiscent of the hotrodded Marshall sound of the late 70's - late 80's, except with more punch, tightness and clarity. I'd like the leads to be very precise and clear, so you can make out every note, and still be fluid - I'm talking something like Paul Gilbert or Muhammed Suicmez. I know Muhammed uses an Engl preamp, but that's out of my price range. I think Paul Gilbert uses one of the higher end Laneys, but I'm pretty sure that's out of my price range also.
With the help of Dave_MC, I've found a couple that may be to my liking (I, of course, plan on trying as many as I can):
> Used Peavey 5150 combo
> Ashdown Fallen Angel
> Randall RG50TC
> B-52 AT combos (the tube ones)
I've tried the B-52 combos - they were decent, but not exactly what I'm looking for. I recall trying a 5150 combo a while back and liking it, but I really don't remember the nuances of the amp well enough to go out and buy one without playing it again. I haven't tried the other two.
Does anybody have any other recommendations for me, or any reinforcement for the ones given already? It seems that, out of the 4 recommended to me, the 5150 would fit me the most - it'd require new tubes and some tweaking, though.
I'm not too knowledgeable on amps - I know what I want most resembles an Engl, but I'm in high school, and sadly can't afford one for a long time.
EDIT:
TL;DR (for those too lazy to read above)
I need a good metal amp with decent cleans but particularly a hot-rodded Marshall crunch rhythm-wise and a really fluid, articulate, precise lead tone, for about USD $600.