Well it depends on what we are actually going to do to be honest.
as if its a song collaberation original/cover then it could quite easily be a mix
if we're doing say a mini contest again it could be a mix.
But if we are doing a pickup contest say we all agree on a track and see which pickup/player can get the closest or get the best vibe then of course it would have to be that way.
What i was thinking was to leave this thread running for a couple of days to get all the people who would be interested into it then as a group decide what it is that we are going to do overall as i was just throwing ideas out there.
A blind tournament could work. It would be drawn out and need plenty of participants, but its not beyond the realm of possibility. Would have to be anonamous, obviously, and we'd need at least 3 or 4 entries per pickup.
The prinicpal difficulty would be whether people are biased, whether they want to be or not, by the tones and production of each clip. They'll be as varied as the clips in players, no doubt, and good playing might be obscured by poor sonics.
But its worth a shot. I dont really see a better way to get the best player, with the best ideas for each pickup. Otherwise its just an 'I bagsy the Miracle Man!', etc etc etc.
Definitely a fan of the tournament though.